|
The Franklin County DemocratThe truth for a change. |
Published by the Franklin County Democratic Central Committee Office: 6908 West Argent, Pasco, Washington US Mail: PO Box 4883, Pasco, Washington 99301 USA Email: news@franklincounty-dems.org |
| www.franklincounty-dems.org | Sunday September 05, 2010 | Weather at 13:22 PDT: |
NEWS
EDITORIAL
OPINION
|
[Format for my printer]
UnforgivenBy David Chassin, Sunday June 22, 2008With all the recent talk of party unity in support of Barack Obama in the run-up to the November election, I still hear rumblings of discontent among some of Hillary's grassroots supporters. It's pretty obvious now that there are two kinds of Hillary supporters, those who like her because she is a Clinton and those who like her because she's a woman. My read of their intentions this fall is very different for these two groups. Clintonites say they will vote for Obama without reservation. Hillary feminists on the other hand tell me they would rather vote for McCain than vote for "that man".
To say I'm disappointed is the understatement of the year.
Hillary's feminists say that the Democratic party has cheated her out of their chance to put a woman in the White House. These are the same feminists who rightly feel they were cheated out of ERA and who naively pushed to hitch Geraldine Ferraro to Mondale's 1984 train wreck. They feel it's long overdue.
However, revenge voting for McCain would be a monumental mistake with historic impact.
For one thing, a McCain win is clearly not going to do anything good for women's issue any time soon. Not only is McCain as old as dirt, but so is his thinking. He doesn't believe in women's issues any more than he believes in health or social issues. Neither does he care.
And the Democratic party has been very good to women for a long time. Hillary's feminists just need to accept that maybe she isn't the best candidate this time and her constant repetition that she is doesn't make it so. Rejecting the chosen candidate is a slap in the face and will reflect badly on all feminists.
Finally, a very serious backlash from the Democratic Party is likely if Hillary's feminists desert Obama, one that will effect all feminists. They are a core constituency that has influenced the party for many years, arguably for the better. Many hold important positions in the Party hierarchy, and their contributions have been critical to the advancement of women's issues and an essential factor in Hillary's success. Without them, the Democratic party would be diminished.
But without the Democratic party, feminists are homeless.
Of course, the flipside is that Obama's base of supporters are relative newcomers to the Party. They are much younger and less experienced at organizing and maneuvering the subtleties of state central committee meetings and conventions. Handing over the organization to them now will hurt. Energy doesn't make up for savvy and experience. If enough feminists desert the party this fall, very serious consequence will follow.
The first is immediate, obvious and the most grievous in my view. Obama will lose to McCain. Women are a key voting block without which a candidate's chances of winning are greatly diminished. For this betrayal alone feminists will never be forgiven. A loss this year would almost certainly have long-term repercussions. Health care, Iraq, debt, energy, environment, you name it, the Republicans could block everything the Democrats are elected to accomplish.
The second is that being unforgiven, feminists will not be welcome in the Democratic Party like before. The local, state, and national committee gavels will be handed to the Obama generation and they won't give them back. They will ostracize and exile all feminists for guilt by association, so that in 2012 Hillary won't stand a change of even being considered, regardless of whether Obama wins this year.
But worst of all will be the devastating blow to women's issues. The younger generation doesn't perceive the residual inequities as anything more than recovery from illness: "It will pass just as soon as those old folks get out of our way."
In any case the feminists will lose the best friend they ever had. The political alliance between feminists and Democrats has been a long and productive one. But it looks like it's in deep trouble. Many traditionally feminist issues like reproductive rights will be recast as health rights, or human rights, or civil rights just to take away the negative association of being attached to anything feminists supported.
What's more some issues like education are not core feminist issues but are typically advocated by the same people. Losing these people will result in significantly reduced focus on these core Democratic issues as well.
It seems to me the height of political naivete and an incredibly short-sighted miscalculation on the part of Hillary's feminists to decamp now just to prove a point. The result will be legislative failure on public education, further erosions of judicial temperament on women issues, many more years of war, the complete demolition of America's labor economy, the further trashing of financial markets by profiteers, and the end of America's robust defense. I can't believe anyone would rather see America plunged further into the mess Bush has made than admit that 2008 wasn't the right time or Hillary wasn't the right person to get a woman in the White House.
It's ironic that just at the cusp of feminism's most dramatic success, we now stand at the edge of the abyss.
It's tragic that Hillary's feminists now seem poised to drag the entire women's movement into oblivion. Send us your comments to Reader's Letters |
Featured LinksPresident Obama's 2010 State of the Union Address |
| http://www.franklincounty-dems.org/news/?3 | 12 - 57 - 158 - 884 - 1794 | Copyright © 2010 Franklin County Democratic Central Committee |